Monday, August 17, 2009

Obama Reads??


I received an email the other day about Obama's reading habits. As it turns out, at least with this one book, his reading habits are exactly mine: The Post American World by Fareed Zakaria.

Zakaria, a naturalized U.S. citizen, was born in India to Muslim parents, and attended a private school in India through Grade 12 that is one of the best in Mumbai. He has been called a conservative, a centrist, and a liberal, and is know for actually paying attention to what’s going on in the world and thinking through issues. He does not identify himself based on party lines or issues, but on logic.

He has a BA from Yale where he was president of the Yale Political Union, and a PhD from Harvard where he directed a research project on American foreign policy. He is currently editor of Newsweek International, has written for the NY Times, Wall Street Journal and others, and hosts CNN’s Fareed Zakaria GPS.

So he’s kinda smart, and has a lot of insight into the world, and his books are well-received by the international political and foreign affairs communities.

The fact that our president is reading his book heartens me. Unlike Bush, who didn’t crack a book and as a result had no clue about anything other than… well, had no clue, Obama actually thinks, and wants to be well-informed, and takes others’ opinions and ideas, and consults experts. Zakaria is one such expert.

But do you know what was appended to this photo? This text:

“The name of the book Obama is reading is called The Post-American World, written by a fellow muslim. Post-America – The world After America ??? Please forward this picture to everyone you know, conservative or liberal to expose Obama's radical ideas and intent for this country!”

So the issues here are legion but I’ll focus only on three.

First, Post American does NOT mean after America, and anyone who reads and believes THAT simply does not understand post-anything in cultural terms. Those people are going to be starting from a foundation that is false; they will therefore come to false conclusions.

Second, this book will not have been read by most people who will be horrified by the photo, and who will believe the implied message in the accompanying text. See above paragraph for false assumptions and false conclusions.

And third, reading a book does not intent prove. Reading Alice in Wonderland does not prove the reader will go eat mushrooms. Reading the Bible does not prove the reader will not commit adultery, steal money from his constituents, or get divorced. Reading Bukowski does not mean one is an alcoholic. And reading a book written by a Muslim does not a Muslim make. (And even if it DID, that is another entire issue for another post - Muslim does not equal bad, evil, wrong, monster, and those who would believe THAT are a whole other problem inherent in this post-9/11 world... and that isn't even addressing the fact that that belief about Muslims has existed for centuries. Again, another post.)

I am incensed and stymied by the masses of America. Are they (yes, ‘they’ – I refuse to be lumped in with them) REALLY this stupid? Are the masses of people really this uneducated, really this gullible, and really this ready to believe the worst of President Obama? Can this implied threat truly be credible to anyone?

I can only shake my head and forge on, and hope that, possibly, the next generation won’t be afraid of becoming educated, and won’t spend their lives wallowing in ignorance and fear.

1 comment:

Vicky Greb said...

The "Bush era" as I think of it was marked by a certain snide disdain for education in general and higher education in particular. I have been scratching my head for years to figure out why Bush was elected in the first place. It seemed obvious he was lying even before he took office. I just read The Great Derangement by Matt Taibbi. In it, he goes undercover at John Hagee's church in Texas. He recounts how the congregation is fed political propoganda along with his particular brand of evangelical religion. What's so interesting is Taibbi's observation of how the congregation receives this information and repeats it without question or independent investigation. In their minds it has become fact. I'm not saying that the churches of this country are leading us astray but there does seem to be a huge swath of this country that is simply not interested in independent thought. And when Bush was in the White House it seemed alot of his winking and nodding was an encouragement to not pay any attention to those silly intellectuals.
Sometimes I find myself frustrated with this President but I do believe that he sets an important example. I heard that Bush read but only as competitive sport. Obama presents us with a leader who is thoughtful and measured in his responses. Perhaps someone who gets this picture will be just a little curious and check out the book. I like to think that at least in ellecting someone of Obama's calliber perhaps we are moving away from our "doofus" period.